News Center
Case Study Sharing from the Panshi Corrosion Hazard Database | Ammonium Chloride Corrosion and Leakage Near the Tower Wall in the Fractionation Tower of a Catalytic Unit Due to Rich Absorption Oil Returning to the Tower
2025-11-28
Basic Information
Device Name
|
Catalytic Unit
|
Device Commissioning Date
|
1993.08
|
Equipment/Pipe Name
|
Fractionation tower
|
Equipment/Pipe Number
|
C-201
|
Specifications and Dimensions
|
Φ3000×12mm
|
Operating medium
|
Oil and gas
|
Main material
|
20G
|
Date of Commissioning
|
1993.08
|
Operating temperature ℃
|
150–160
|
Operating pressure MPa
|
/
|
Background
In 2025, a leak occurred on the tower wall adjacent to the rich-absorbent-oil return line at the 10th floor platform of the fractionation tower in a certain enterprise’s catalytic unit, as shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1: On-site Diagram of the Leak Location on the Fractionation Tower
Eddy current inspections conducted in response to this leak revealed severe wall thinning around the leak point, with a minimum wall thickness of 3.3 mm and a thinning rate of 72.5%. Significant thinning was also observed within the same horizontal zone on the right side of the leak point, spanning approximately 30–40 cm in length and 5 cm in width. On the west side of the tenth-floor platform tower, areas with wall thinning exceeding 50% were identified, while zones with thinning greater than 30% were found near the jet fuel withdrawal line. All of these thinned areas and the leak location are situated at the same horizontal elevation—25 cm above the insulation cotton support ring—and correspond to the liquid collection tray within the tower’s internal structure.
Process Flow Research
The leak in the fractionation tower is located near the point where the rich absorbent oil returns to the tower. The rich absorbent oil discharged from the bottom of the reabsorption tower is returned between the two packing sections of the fractionation tower, with a return temperature of around 88°C and an internal tower temperature of approximately 150–160°C.
![]()

Figure 2: Process Flow Diagram
Corrosion Analysis
1) Corrosion Mechanism Identification
Leakage and thinning in the fractionation tower may be caused by ammonium chloride corrosion. The leakage occurs near the rich absorbent oil reflux line into the tower, where the rich absorbent oil is returned at a temperature of approximately 90°C. When the rich absorbent oil flows back into the fractionation tower, it can lead to the formation of localized low‑temperature zones within the tower. Based on the operating data for this unit at the time, the calculated crystallization temperature of ammonium salts is around 147°C, while the dew point temperature of the fractionation tower is about 98°C, which may result in the formation of liquid water. The temperature in these localized low‑temperature zones falls below the salt‑forming temperature of ammonium chloride, and the presence of liquid water further increases the likelihood of ammonium chloride corrosion occurring inside the tower.
A key characteristic of the leakage and thinning areas in this distillation column is that the thinning occurs horizontally at the same elevation, located 25 centimeters above the insulation cotton support ring. The corresponding internal structure in this region is the liquid collection tray. Analysis indicates that ammonium chloride tends to accumulate and form scale at the junction between the liquid collection tray and the tower wall, leading to under‑deposition corrosion caused by ammonium chloride fouling.
The following provides a separate analysis of the effects of ammonium chloride corrosion from two perspectives: raw material properties and process parameters. The specific details are as follows:
(1) The Influence of Raw Material Properties
The nitrogen and chlorine content of the mixed feedstock at the II catalytic unit were analyzed and statistically summarized over a three‑year period, as shown in Figure 3. Before the major overhaul in 2023, the average nitrogen content was 2,998 mg/kg and the average chlorine content was 3.49 mg/kg; after the major overhaul in 2023, the average nitrogen content rose to 4,240 mg/kg, while the average chlorine content increased to 4.4 mg/kg.
It can be seen that after maintenance, the nitrogen and chlorine content in the raw materials used for processing are relatively high, which has increased the risk of ammonium chloride corrosion within the tower.
Figure 3: Analysis Data on Nitrogen and Chlorine Content in Mixed Raw Materials
(2) The Impact of Process Changes
From a process parameter perspective, the corrosion caused by ammonium chloride may be attributed to the excessively low return temperature of the rich absorbent oil to the tower. The following figure shows the statistical distribution of the rich absorbent oil return temperature after the major overhaul in 2023. It can be observed that from the start of the major overhaul through May 2024, the return temperature of the rich absorbent oil was relatively high, reaching as high as approximately 130°C, with an average temperature of 115°C. Following process adjustments made in May 2024, the return temperature of the rich absorbent oil decreased; since May 2024, the average temperature has been 94°C, with the lowest recorded temperature dropping as low as 86°C. An excessively low return temperature of the rich absorbent oil may lead to the formation of localized low‑temperature zones within the fractionation tower (temperatures below the ammonium chloride salt‑forming temperature of 147°C), thereby promoting NH₄Cl crystallization and exacerbating ammonium chloride corrosion.
Figure 4: Trend of Reflux Tower Temperature for Oil with High Absorption Capacity
2) Corrosion Circuit Analysis
The temperature inside the tower at the leak location is around 150–160°C, and the circuit is divided into a low-temperature circuit for the fractionation tower.
3) Material Analysis
The fractionation tower is made of 20G steel without an internal lining, which has relatively low material quality and poor resistance to ammonium chloride corrosion.
Conclusions and Recommendations
1) Conclusion
This is caused by ammonium chloride corrosion in the fractionation tower. The low return temperature of the rich absorbent oil to the tower leads to the formation of localized low‑temperature zones within the fractionation tower. Since the temperature in these localized low‑temperature zones falls below the salt‑forming temperature of ammonium chloride, and given the presence of liquid water, ammonium chloride corrosion is prone to occur inside the tower. Moreover, the high nitrogen and chlorine content in the feedstock further exacerbates the risk of ammonium chloride corrosion within the tower.
The leak is located at a liquid‑collecting tray within the tower. At the intersection of the liquid‑collecting tray and the tower wall, ammonium chloride tends to accumulate and form scale, leading to under‑deposition corrosion caused by ammonium chloride deposits.
2) Recommendations
① In terms of process optimization, increase the temperature of the rich absorbent oil as it returns to the tower to prevent an increased risk of ammonium chloride corrosion caused by excessively low return temperatures.
② During shutdowns, conduct thorough inspections above the tower for the highly absorbent oil; if necessary, upgrade the fractionation tower material to carbon steel plus 0Cr13 (or 0Cr13Al).
Implications of this case
This corrosion case exhibits certain unique characteristics; the corrosion leak occurred in a location that typically receives little attention. The following is a reminder for refining and chemical enterprises, as well as companies engaged in on-site corrosion protection services:
- Major Overhaul Corrosion Inspection: During the initial data collection phase, it is recommended to pay close attention to the temperature conditions in the diesel reflux section below the top of the catalytic fractionation column. If the reflux temperature is significantly lower than the design operating conditions—and notably below the salt deposition temperature of ammonium chloride—special emphasis should be placed on this area during internal inspections of the tower.
- Routine Hazard Identification: In daily operations, pay close attention to temperature fluctuations in the low‑temperature reflux sections of catalytic fractionation towers, hydrotreating stripping towers, fractionation towers, and coking fractionation towers to prevent salt deposition caused by localized low temperatures within the towers due to cold reflux. When inspecting the tower wall of the low‑temperature system at the tower top, it is best to consult the equipment drawings and focus on the areas around the trays, downcomers, and receiving pans, conducting circumferential scans.
- Daily Corrosion Control: Monitor the temperatures of the top reflux draw, top reflux to tower, diesel draw, diesel vapor phase to tower, and rich absorbent oil to tower, and compare them with the ammonium chloride crystallization temperature at the tower top. If the temperature falls below the salt‑forming temperature, identify potential risks of ammonium chloride scaling and develop corresponding prevention and control measures.
Shenyang Zhongke Weier Anti-Corrosion Technology Center
2015.11.27